Sincere, Corbin Mims and the “two fishes” line behind a TikTok sound, explained
Trend roundups credit Corbin Mims. Today.com's reunion recap says the line is Sincere's. Here is what each source actually says.
The tea in 3
- The “Two Fishes” TikTok sound turns questionable opinions into straight-faced arguments; it comes from Love Island USA Season 8.
- Today.com's reunion recap credits Sincere: “just because you have two fishes, you got to like, put one back.”
- Trend roundups from New Engen and The Weekly Scroll attribute the clip to Corbin Mims, nicknamed “CorbinGPT.”
You have probably seen the “Two Fishes” sound: someone lip-syncs a clip, then defends something indefensible with total calm. The sound comes from Love Island USA Season 8, but who gets credit depends on which source you read.
What the trend is
New Engen’s October trend report describes creators lip-syncing to the audio while defending questionable opinions “with complete seriousness.” The Weekly Scroll, a newsletter, says people use it to defend everything from unnecessary shopping sprees to making plans when they should probably stay home.
Who said the line?
vs
Today.com’s reunion live blog gives the original quote as Sincere’s confessional line: “So it’s not like just because you have two fishes, you got to like, put one back.”
The Weekly Scroll says the trend “comes from a clip of Corbin Mims on Love Island USA, where he explains that just because you have two fish doesn’t mean you need to put one back.” New Engen lists Mims as the credited contestant.
The sources differ, and none of the three we read settles who is speaking on the TikTok sound itself, so we are not guessing.
The reunion callback
The Season 8 reunion streamed on Peacock on Aug 31, hosted by Ariana Madix and Andy Cohen. Melanie joked about her Blindfold Challenge choice to kiss Corbin by referencing the line, according to Today. She asked Andy and Ariana if they knew the quote and mimed weighing fish in her hands.
Ariana finished it: “It’s like when I have two beautiful fish, why put one back?”
The timeline
- The reunion airs. Melanie and Ariana quote the line on camera.
- New Engen’s October TikTok trend report lists “Two Fishes” at #1.
- The Weekly Scroll says creators are using the sound for all kinds of bad logic.
Why it matters
It is a reminder that the person on a viral sound is not always the person who came up with the line. When there is a conflict, check the show. Today.com’s recap, which quotes the confessional, credits Sincere with the line.
Poll
Two fishes: do you keep both?
Your reaction?
Receipts
Where this story comes from. We link primary posts and the outlets that reported them.
Something wrong or missing? Send a correction · How we report
